Free Evaluation
Free Evaluation

What Is the Sabine Pilot Exception in Texas?

The Sabine Pilot exception is Texas’s only state-law protection against wrongful termination for refusing to commit an illegal act. Named after the 1985 Texas Supreme Court case Sabine Pilot Service v. Hauck, this narrow exception allows employees to sue if they are fired specifically because they refused to perform an illegal activity their employer demanded.

This is the only public policy exception to at-will employment that Texas state courts recognize. Unlike California or New York, which have broad public policy protections for workers, Texas limits this exception to one specific situation: refusing to break the law when ordered to do so by your employer.

Understanding how narrow this exception is can save you time and legal fees if you believe your termination was wrongful but does not meet this high standard.

Why the Sabine Pilot Exception Matters

Texas has one of the strongest at-will employment doctrines in the United States. Your employer can fire you for almost any reason or no reason at all. The Sabine Pilot exception creates a limited safety valve: employers cannot force you to choose between keeping your job and committing a crime.

This protection exists because Texas courts recognize that public policy is harmed when employers coerce workers into illegal conduct. However, the exception is applied extremely narrowly. Texas courts consistently reject attempts to expand Sabine Pilot beyond its original scope.

Most workers who believe they have a Sabine Pilot claim discover their situation does not qualify. Before pursuing this type of claim, you need a realistic understanding of what the exception covers.

The Sabine Pilot Case: Where This Exception Comes From

In 1985, the Texas Supreme Court decided Sabine Pilot Service v. Hauck. The case involved a boat captain who was fired after refusing his employer’s order to pump ship bilges (waste water) into the waterway, which violated federal pollution laws.

The captain refused because the activity was illegal under the Federal Refuse Act. His employer fired him. The captain sued for wrongful termination. The Texas Supreme Court ruled that an at-will employee could sue for termination if fired “for the sole reason that the employee refused to perform an illegal act.”

This landmark decision created Texas’s only state-law public policy exception to at-will employment. However, courts have interpreted this exception very narrowly in the 40 years since the decision.

What the Sabine Pilot Exception Protects

To have a valid Sabine Pilot claim, you must prove:

  1. Your employer ordered you to perform a specific illegal act
  2. You refused to perform that illegal act
  3. Your employer fired you specifically because of your refusal
  4. The sole reason for your termination was your refusal

All four elements are required. If any element is missing, your claim fails.

Element 1: Employer Ordered Illegal Act

Your employer must have explicitly directed you to do something that violates criminal or civil law. The illegal conduct must be:

  • Specific: A clear directive to do a particular illegal thing
  • From someone with authority: Usually your supervisor or company leadership
  • Actually illegal: Violates a specific statute or regulation

Vague requests, unethical but legal conduct, and situations where you suspected illegal activity but were not ordered to participate usually do not qualify.

Element 2: You Refused

You must have clearly refused to perform the illegal act. Simply feeling uncomfortable or passively failing to comply is not enough. You need evidence that you:

  • Communicated your refusal to your employer
  • Explained that the requested conduct was illegal (in most cases)
  • Declined to participate despite pressure or consequences

If you performed the illegal act even once before refusing, your claim may be weakened or eliminated.

Element 3: Fired Because of Refusal

Your termination must be causally connected to your refusal. Timing is important. If you refused an illegal order and were fired shortly afterward, this supports causation.

However, if your employer provides a different reason for your termination (poor performance, policy violations, restructuring), you must prove that reason is pretextual (a lie covering the real reason).

Element 4: Sole Reason

This is often the most difficult element. Many courts require that your refusal to commit an illegal act was the sole reason for your termination. If your employer had multiple reasons for firing you—even if refusing illegal conduct was one reason—your Sabine Pilot claim may fail.

This strict interpretation makes Sabine Pilot claims difficult to prove in practice.

What the Sabine Pilot Exception Does NOT Protect

Texas courts have consistently rejected Sabine Pilot claims in these situations:

Reporting Illegal Activity (Whistleblowing)

The Sabine Pilot exception protects refusing to commit illegal acts yourself. It usually does not protect reporting illegal activity you observe.

Example: You discover your company is committing tax fraud. You report this to your supervisor. The company fires you. This is not protected by Sabine Pilot because you were not ordered to commit the illegal act and fired for refusing. You reported someone else’s illegal conduct.

Some federal and state whistleblower statutes may protect you in this situation, but Sabine Pilot does not.

Refusing Unethical but Legal Conduct

Your employer can fire you for refusing to do something unethical if that conduct is not illegal.

Example: Your employer tells you to lie to customers about product features in a way that is misleading but not technically fraud. You refuse. The company fires you. This is not protected by Sabine Pilot because the conduct, while unethical, may not violate a specific law.

Complaining About Workplace Issues

Complaining about safety violations, discrimination, or other workplace problems is not protected by Sabine Pilot unless you were specifically ordered to commit an illegal act and fired for refusing.

Example: You complain to HR about unsafe working conditions. Your employer fires you in retaliation. This is not a Sabine Pilot claim (though it may violate OSHA retaliation provisions or other specific statutes).

Refusing to Violate Company Policy

Internal company policies are not laws. Your employer can fire you for refusing to follow company rules, even if those rules seem unfair or arbitrary.

Constructive Discharge

If your employer makes working conditions intolerable to force you to quit, this is not a Sabine Pilot claim. Sabine Pilot requires actual termination, not resignation.

Learn more about constructive discharge for information on this concept.

Performing Illegal Act Under Duress

If you performed the illegal act because you felt you had no choice, you generally cannot later bring a Sabine Pilot claim. The exception protects those who refuse illegal orders, not those who comply.

Real-World Examples of Sabine Pilot Claims

These examples show when the Sabine Pilot exception applies and when it does not:

Example 1: Valid Sabine Pilot Claim

Situation: Miguel worked as an accountant for a small manufacturing company. His supervisor ordered him to falsify financial records submitted to the IRS to reduce the company’s tax liability. Miguel refused, explaining that this constituted tax fraud. The supervisor told him, “Either you fix these numbers or you’re done here.” Miguel refused again. The company fired him three days later, stating “performance issues” as the reason.

Analysis: This likely qualifies as a Sabine Pilot claim. Miguel was ordered to commit a specific illegal act (tax fraud), clearly refused, and was fired shortly after his refusal. The timing and supervisor’s statement support that his refusal was the reason for termination.

Example 2: Does NOT Qualify – Reporting Wrongdoing

Situation: Jennifer worked in HR and discovered her company was misclassifying employees as independent contractors to avoid payroll taxes. She reported this to the CEO. The company investigated and disagreed with her assessment. They fired her two weeks later for “not fitting company culture.”

Analysis: This does not qualify as a Sabine Pilot claim. Jennifer was not ordered to commit an illegal act herself. She reported illegal activity she discovered. While this seems like retaliation for whistleblowing, Sabine Pilot only protects refusing illegal orders, not reporting violations.

Example 3: Does NOT Qualify – Unethical but Legal

Situation: Robert worked in sales. His manager told him to use high-pressure tactics to push elderly customers into contracts they did not need. Robert felt this was predatory and refused. The company fired him for “failing to meet sales targets.”

Analysis: This does not qualify unless the sales tactics violated a specific consumer protection statute. Unethical conduct that is not illegal does not trigger Sabine Pilot protection.

Example 4: Valid Sabine Pilot Claim

Situation: Carmen worked as a truck driver. Her dispatcher ordered her to continue driving after she had exceeded the legal hours-of-service limits under federal Department of Transportation regulations. Carmen refused, citing the violation. The dispatcher said, “If you don’t get this load delivered, don’t bother coming back.” Carmen refused. She was fired the next day.

Analysis: This likely qualifies. Carmen was ordered to violate specific federal transportation regulations, clearly refused, and was fired immediately after. The timing and dispatcher’s statement support causation.

Example 5: Does NOT Qualify – Complaining About Safety

Situation: David worked in construction. He complained to his supervisor about unsafe scaffolding that violated OSHA standards. The supervisor told him to stop complaining and get back to work. David continued to raise concerns. He was fired a week later for “insubordination.”

Analysis: This does not qualify as a Sabine Pilot claim. David was not ordered to perform an illegal act. He complained about safety violations. OSHA has separate anti-retaliation provisions that may protect David, but this is not a Sabine Pilot case.

Example 6: Does NOT Qualify – Multiple Reasons for Termination

Situation: Lisa worked as an office manager. Her boss asked her to shred documents that were subject to a legal hold. Lisa refused, explaining this would be obstruction of justice. However, Lisa also had attendance issues and had received two written warnings about tardiness. The company fired her, citing both the document refusal and attendance problems.

Analysis: This likely does not qualify. Even though Lisa refused an illegal order, the company had other documented reasons for termination. The “sole reason” requirement means mixed-motive cases often fail.

Example 7: Valid Sabine Pilot Claim

Situation: Eric worked at a medical clinic. His supervisor ordered him to submit false billing codes to Medicare to increase reimbursement. Eric refused, stating this was Medicare fraud. The supervisor pressured him repeatedly. Eric continued to refuse. He was fired one week later with no reason given.

Analysis: This likely qualifies. Medicare fraud is clearly illegal, Eric was specifically ordered to commit it, he refused, and the timing of termination shortly after his refusal supports causation.

Example 8: Does NOT Qualify – Constructive Discharge

Situation: After refusing to participate in a scheme to bill customers for services not provided, Angela faced constant hostility from management. Her hours were cut, she was moved to a worse shift, and she was excluded from meetings. After two months, Angela resigned because conditions were intolerable.

Analysis: This does not qualify under Sabine Pilot. The exception requires actual termination, not resignation (even under pressure). Angela may have other legal claims, but not under Sabine Pilot.

Example 9: Does NOT Qualify – Performed Illegal Act Before Refusing

Situation: Thomas worked in finance and initially complied with his supervisor’s requests to manipulate account records. After several months, Thomas became uncomfortable and refused to continue. He was fired shortly after refusing.

Analysis: This likely does not qualify. Thomas participated in illegal conduct before refusing. Courts may find he cannot claim protection after initially complying.

Example 10: Borderline Case – Ambiguous Whether Act Was Illegal

Situation: Maria’s employer asked her to send marketing emails to a purchased list of contacts who had not consented to receive communications. Maria believed this violated CAN-SPAM Act regulations and refused. The company disagreed with her interpretation of the law. They fired her for “not being a team player.”

Analysis: This is borderline. The case turns on whether the requested conduct actually violated the law. If Maria can prove the email campaign would have violated federal regulations, she may have a claim. If the legality is debatable, her claim likely fails.

How to Prove a Sabine Pilot Claim

Sabine Pilot claims are difficult to win. You need strong evidence proving all required elements.

Evidence That Strengthens Your Claim

  • Written orders: Emails or text messages directing you to perform illegal acts
  • Contemporaneous notes: Documentation you created at the time recording what you were asked to do
  • Witness testimony: Coworkers who heard the illegal orders or your refusal
  • Your refusal documented: Evidence you told your employer you would not comply
  • Timing: Being fired immediately after refusing supports causation
  • Admission by employer: Statements linking your termination to your refusal
  • No other performance issues: Clean record before refusing illegal order
  • Pretext evidence: Showing the employer’s stated reason for firing you is false

Evidence That Weakens Your Claim

  • No clear directive: Vague or implied suggestions rather than direct orders
  • Performed the act: Evidence you complied even once before refusing
  • Legitimate performance issues: Documentation of other problems justifying termination
  • Long gap between refusal and termination: Weeks or months between events
  • Ambiguous legality: Debate about whether the requested conduct was actually illegal
  • Mixed motives: Multiple reasons for your termination

Burden of Proof

You must prove your case by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not). This means you need to show it is more probable than not that each required element exists.

Your employer will likely argue:

  • They never ordered you to do anything illegal
  • You were fired for legitimate reasons unrelated to any refusal
  • The conduct was not actually illegal
  • There were multiple reasons for termination

You must overcome these defenses with credible evidence.

Texas vs. California and New York Public Policy Protections

Texas’s Sabine Pilot exception is far narrower than public policy protections in worker-friendly states:

Protection Type Texas (Sabine Pilot) California New York
Refusing to commit illegal act Yes (only protection) Yes Yes
Reporting illegal activity (whistleblowing) No (not under Sabine Pilot) Yes (broad protection) Yes (moderate protection)
Exercising statutory rights Only if specific statute provides Yes (broad) Yes (moderate)
Refusing to violate professional ethics No Sometimes Sometimes
Jury duty Protected by separate statute Protected Protected
Filing workers’ comp claim Protected by separate statute Protected Protected
Refusing to take lie detector test Protected by federal law Protected Protected
Other public policy violations No Yes (many recognized) Yes (several recognized)

California courts have recognized wrongful termination claims for dozens of public policy violations. New York provides moderate protections. Texas provides only the Sabine Pilot exception at the state level, plus protections under specific federal statutes.

If you researched wrongful termination in other states, do not assume similar protections exist in Texas.

Other Laws That May Protect You

Even if your situation does not qualify under Sabine Pilot, other laws may provide protection:

Federal Anti-Retaliation Statutes

Many federal laws prohibit retaliation for specific protected activities:

  • Title VII: Retaliation for reporting discrimination or participating in investigation
  • OSHA: Retaliation for reporting safety violations (11 days to file complaint!)
  • Sarbanes-Oxley Act: Whistleblower protection for public company employees reporting fraud
  • Dodd-Frank Act: Whistleblower protection for reporting securities violations to SEC
  • False Claims Act: Protection for reporting fraud against government
  • Clean Air Act / Clean Water Act: Environmental whistleblower protections

These statutes have specific filing deadlines and procedures. Many require filing with federal agencies before you can sue.

See our guide to Texas Workplace Retaliation for more information.

Texas Whistleblower Statutes

Texas has limited whistleblower protection for public employees and certain private sector workers. These statutes are narrow and have specific requirements.

Private sector workers generally have minimal whistleblower protection under Texas state law.

Industry-Specific Protections

Certain industries have additional protections:

  • Healthcare workers reporting patient safety issues (limited)
  • Financial services workers reporting fraud
  • Transportation workers reporting safety violations

Statute of Limitations for Sabine Pilot Claims

Sabine Pilot claims are common law tort claims. They follow Texas’s general tort statute of limitations.

You have two years from the date of termination to file a lawsuit in state court. This deadline is strict. If you miss it, your claim is permanently barred.

This is different from discrimination claims, which require filing administrative charges within 180-300 days. Sabine Pilot claims do not require administrative exhaustion—you can file directly in court.

However, two years goes by quickly. Do not delay if you believe you have a Sabine Pilot claim.

Learn more about timing requirements in our guide to wrongful termination statute of limitations.

Damages Available for Sabine Pilot Claims

If you successfully prove a Sabine Pilot claim, you may recover:

  • Lost wages: Back pay from termination until judgment or new employment
  • Future lost earnings: If you cannot find comparable employment
  • Emotional distress damages: Compensation for mental anguish, humiliation, anxiety
  • Punitive damages: If your employer’s conduct was particularly egregious (rare)
  • Attorney fees and costs: In some cases (not guaranteed)

Unlike federal Title VII discrimination claims, Sabine Pilot claims have no statutory damage caps. However, juries must still find damages reasonable and supported by evidence.

Emotional distress damages require more than just testimony that you felt upset. You typically need evidence such as:

  • Medical records showing treatment for depression or anxiety
  • Medication prescribed due to job loss stress
  • Expert testimony about psychological harm
  • Documentation of how termination affected your life

See our complete guide to wrongful termination damages for details.

Should You Pursue a Sabine Pilot Claim?

Most workers who believe they have Sabine Pilot claims discover their situations do not qualify. Before investing time and money in litigation, honestly assess your case:

You May Have a Valid Claim If:

  • Your employer explicitly ordered you to break a specific law
  • You clearly refused and communicated your refusal
  • You were fired very soon after refusing (days or weeks, not months)
  • You have written evidence of the illegal order
  • You have no documented performance problems
  • You never complied with the illegal order

You Probably Do NOT Have a Valid Claim If:

  • You reported illegal activity but were not ordered to participate
  • The conduct was unethical but not clearly illegal
  • You were fired for complaining about company policies or practices
  • You complied with illegal orders before refusing
  • You have performance issues or policy violations in your record
  • Months passed between your refusal and your termination
  • Your employer has documented legitimate reasons for termination

Next Steps

If you believe you may have a Sabine Pilot claim:

  1. Document everything immediately: Write down what happened while details are fresh
  2. Preserve evidence: Save emails, text messages, and any documents related to the illegal order
  3. Consult an employment attorney: Most offer free consultations to evaluate your case
  4. Do not wait: You have two years to file, but evidence gets stale and witnesses’ memories fade
  5. Be realistic: An experienced attorney will tell you honestly if your case fits the narrow Sabine Pilot requirements

Many employment attorneys in Texas rarely see valid Sabine Pilot claims. These cases are the exception, not the rule.

Common Questions About the Sabine Pilot Exception

Does Sabine Pilot protect me if I report illegal activity?

No. Sabine Pilot only protects employees who refuse to commit illegal acts themselves. Reporting illegal activity you observe (whistleblowing) is not covered unless a specific whistleblower statute applies.

What if my employer asked me to do something I thought was illegal but maybe wasn’t?

Your belief must be objectively reasonable and the conduct must actually be illegal. If you refuse to do something that turns out to be legal, you have no Sabine Pilot protection. The ambiguity may make your case difficult to win.

Can I be fired for refusing to lie to customers?

It depends whether the lie violates a specific statute (such as consumer fraud laws). Unethical conduct that is not criminal or civilly illegal does not trigger Sabine Pilot protection.

What if I complied once before refusing?

This significantly weakens or eliminates your claim. Courts may find you cannot claim protection after initially participating in illegal conduct.

Does Sabine Pilot apply to all Texas employers?

Yes. Unlike federal discrimination laws that only cover employers of certain sizes, Sabine Pilot applies to all Texas employers regardless of size. However, proving a claim is still very difficult.

What if I was fired for refusing to work off the clock?

This may violate wage and hour laws rather than Sabine Pilot. The Fair Labor Standards Act and Texas Payday Law provide separate protections. Consult our guide to Texas Wages and Hours.

Can I sue immediately or do I need to file with a government agency first?

Sabine Pilot claims go directly to state court. You do not need to file with the EEOC, TWC, or any agency first. However, you only have two years from termination to file.

What if my employer made me sign a confidentiality agreement?

Confidentiality agreements cannot prevent you from reporting illegal activity to law enforcement or government agencies. However, consult an attorney before disclosing information covered by such agreements.

Will I definitely win if I have a valid Sabine Pilot claim?

No. Even valid claims can lose at trial. Your employer will vigorously defend, often arguing they had other reasons for termination or that the conduct was not actually illegal. Success is never guaranteed.

How much does it cost to pursue a Sabine Pilot claim?

Many employment attorneys work on contingency (taking a percentage of recovery if you win). However, not all cases are accepted on contingency. Complicated or weak cases may require you to pay hourly fees. Discuss fee arrangements during your consultation.

What if I quit because they were pressuring me to do illegal things?

Sabine Pilot requires actual termination, not resignation. If you quit, you generally cannot bring a Sabine Pilot claim even if you felt you had no choice. See our guide to constructive discharge for limited exceptions.

Understanding Texas’s Narrow Public Policy Protection

The Sabine Pilot exception is Texas’s only state-law public policy protection for at-will employees. It applies only when you are fired specifically for refusing to commit an illegal act your employer ordered you to perform.

Most situations that feel like wrongful termination do not qualify. Texas courts have consistently rejected attempts to expand Sabine Pilot beyond this narrow scope.

If your situation involves reporting illegal activity, complaining about workplace issues, or refusing unethical but legal conduct, Sabine Pilot does not protect you. You may have protections under specific federal or state statutes, but the bar for proving those claims is also high.

Before pursuing a Sabine Pilot claim, get a realistic assessment from an experienced Texas employment attorney. Most wrongful termination cases in Texas fail because they do not fit within the narrow exceptions to at-will employment.

References

Disclaimer: The information provided on this page is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Employment laws vary by state and change frequently. For advice specific to your situation, please consult with a licensed employment attorney in your state. Employment Law Aid is not a law firm and does not provide legal representation.