Free Evaluation
Free Evaluation

What Are Public Policy Exceptions to At-Will Employment in Texas?

Public policy exceptions to at-will employment allow workers to sue for wrongful termination when their firing violates an important public interest. However, Texas recognizes only one state-law public policy exception: the Sabine Pilot doctrine, which protects employees fired for refusing to commit illegal acts.

This is the reality: Texas provides minimal public policy protection compared to states like California or New York. Most wrongful termination protections in Texas come from federal law, not state law. If you are researching whether you can sue your Texas employer for wrongful discharge based on public policy, you need realistic expectations about your limited options.

Understanding what public policy exceptions exist—and what does not exist—in Texas helps you assess whether you have a valid legal claim or need to focus on moving forward.

Why Public Policy Exceptions Matter

At-will employment in Texas means your employer can fire you for almost any reason. Public policy exceptions are supposed to create a safety net when termination harms important societal interests.

In worker-friendly states, courts recognize many public policy exceptions:

  • Refusing to violate professional ethics
  • Reporting illegal activity to authorities (whistleblowing)
  • Exercising legal rights (serving on jury, filing workers’ comp claims)
  • Refusing to submit to illegal drug testing
  • Other situations where termination undermines public welfare

Texas courts reject most of these protections. The Texas Supreme Court has repeatedly declined to expand public policy exceptions beyond the narrow Sabine Pilot rule.

This means most situations that would support wrongful termination claims in other states provide no recourse in Texas unless federal law applies.

The Only Texas State-Law Public Policy Exception: Sabine Pilot

Texas recognizes exactly one public policy exception to at-will employment at the state level:

The Sabine Pilot Exception: You cannot be fired for refusing to perform an illegal act your employer orders you to commit.

This protection comes from the 1985 Texas Supreme Court case Sabine Pilot Service v. Hauck. The court held that terminating an employee “for the sole reason that the employee refused to perform an illegal act” violates public policy.

What Sabine Pilot Protects

The exception is extremely narrow. You must prove:

  1. Your employer ordered you to commit a specific illegal act
  2. You refused to commit that illegal act
  3. You were fired specifically because of your refusal
  4. Your refusal was the sole reason for termination

If any element is missing, your claim fails.

Example of valid Sabine Pilot claim: Your supervisor orders you to falsify records submitted to a government agency. You refuse because this is fraud. Your employer fires you three days later. This may qualify.

Example that does NOT qualify: You report safety violations to OSHA. Your employer fires you in retaliation. This is not protected under Sabine Pilot because you were not ordered to commit an illegal act—you reported violations.

For complete details, see our guide to Sabine Pilot exception.

Public Policy Exceptions Texas Does NOT Recognize

Texas courts have consistently rejected public policy wrongful termination claims in these situations:

Whistleblowing (Reporting Illegal Activity)

California and New York: Broad protection for employees who report illegal activity to authorities or internally.

Texas: No general whistleblower protection under public policy exception. Sabine Pilot only protects refusing to commit illegal acts yourself, not reporting violations you observe.

Example: You discover your company is defrauding customers and report it to your supervisor. You are fired. Texas common law does not protect you unless a specific statute applies.

Limited federal and state whistleblower statutes provide narrow protections for specific types of reporting (see below), but these are statutory protections, not public policy common law claims.

Exercising Statutory Rights

California and New York: Protection for exercising legal rights like voting, serving on jury duty, or filing workers’ compensation claims.

Texas: No general public policy protection. However, specific statutes prohibit retaliation for certain activities:

  • Jury duty: Texas law prohibits firing employees for jury service
  • Workers’ compensation: Separate statute prohibits retaliation for filing claims
  • Voting: Protected by federal and state law

These are statutory protections, not public policy exceptions to at-will employment. The distinction matters because you must comply with specific procedural requirements and deadlines for each statute.

Professional Ethics and Standards

California: Protection for professionals (doctors, lawyers, accountants) fired for following ethical obligations.

Texas: No general protection. You can be fired for refusing to violate your professional ethics unless the conduct your employer demands is criminal or the specific profession has statutory protection.

Example: An accountant refuses to prepare financial statements in a misleading (but not illegal) manner. The employer fires her. Texas provides no public policy protection.

Refusing Immoral or Unethical Conduct

California and New York: Sometimes protect employees who refuse conduct that violates public policy even if not explicitly illegal.

Texas: No protection. Unethical conduct that is not illegal does not trigger Sabine Pilot or any other public policy exception.

Example: You refuse to lie to customers about product features in a way that is misleading but not technically fraud. You are fired. This is legal in Texas.

Internal Complaints About Violations

California: Protection for internal complaints about illegal conduct or policy violations.

Texas: No protection under public policy exception. Making internal complaints does not prevent at-will termination unless a specific statute applies.

Example: You complain to HR about discriminatory practices. HR investigates and disagrees. You are fired two weeks later. Unless this violates Title VII’s anti-retaliation provisions, Texas common law does not protect you.

Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing

California: Limited recognition that employers must act in good faith.

Texas: No recognition of implied covenant in employment context. Employers can make unfair or bad faith decisions as long as they are not discriminatory or retaliatory under specific statutes.

Federal Law: Your Primary Protection in Texas

Because Texas state law provides minimal public policy protection, federal statutes are your primary recourse for wrongful termination claims.

Federal Anti-Discrimination Laws

These laws protect you from termination based on specific characteristics:

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act (employers with 15+ employees):

  • Race, color, national origin, religion, sex (including pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity)
  • Also prohibits retaliation for reporting discrimination or participating in investigations

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) (employers with 15+ employees):

  • Protects workers with disabilities
  • Requires reasonable accommodation
  • Prohibits discrimination and retaliation

Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) (employers with 20+ employees):

  • Protects workers age 40 and older from age-based discrimination
  • Prohibits retaliation

Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) (employers with 50+ employees):

  • Protects eligible employees taking leave for covered reasons
  • Prohibits retaliation for exercising FMLA rights

See our comprehensive guide to Texas Workplace Discrimination for details.

Federal Whistleblower Protections

Numerous federal statutes prohibit retaliation for reporting specific violations:

Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA):

  • Protects workers who report safety violations
  • Covers numerous industries and violation types
  • Very short deadline: 11 days to 180 days depending on the specific provision
  • File complaint with OSHA, not court

Sarbanes-Oxley Act:

  • Protects employees of public companies who report securities fraud
  • 180-day deadline to file with OSHA
  • Can lead to federal court lawsuit

Dodd-Frank Act:

  • Protects whistleblowers who report securities violations to SEC
  • Can receive financial rewards for information leading to enforcement actions

False Claims Act:

  • Protects employees who report fraud against government
  • “Qui tam” provisions allow whistleblowers to sue on behalf of government

Environmental whistleblower laws:

  • Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, and others protect reporting environmental violations
  • Various deadlines (often 30 days)

Financial services whistleblower protections:

  • Multiple statutes protect banking and financial industry whistleblowers

These federal statutes have specific procedures and deadlines. Many require filing complaints with federal agencies (OSHA, SEC, etc.) before you can sue in court. Missing deadlines typically kills your claim.

See our guide to Texas Workplace Retaliation for comprehensive information about retaliation protections.

Other Federal Employment Protections

National Labor Relations Act (NLRA):

  • Protects workers discussing wages and working conditions
  • Applies to most private sector workers (even non-union)
  • Prohibits firing for “protected concerted activity”

Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA):

  • Prohibits retaliation for reporting wage and hour violations

WARN Act:

  • Requires advance notice for mass layoffs at large employers
  • No direct “public policy” protection, but creates procedural requirements

Limited Texas Whistleblower Statutes

Texas has a few narrow whistleblower statutes that provide limited protection:

Texas Whistleblower Act (Public Employees)

The Texas Whistleblower Act protects public employees (state, county, municipal workers) who report violations of law to appropriate authorities. This statute does not cover private sector employees in most cases.

Key requirements:

  • You must be a public employee
  • You must report violations in good faith
  • You must report to appropriate authority (not just internal complaints in all cases)

Private sector workers generally cannot use this statute.

Healthcare Whistleblower Protections

Texas has limited protections for healthcare workers who report patient care issues. These protections are narrow and apply only to specific situations.

Other Industry-Specific Protections

Certain Texas statutes protect specific industries or situations:

  • Insurance industry whistleblowers (limited)
  • Financial services workers (limited state protections beyond federal)

These statutes have specific requirements and are not broadly applicable.

Texas vs. California and New York: How Public Policy Protections Compare

The gap between Texas and worker-friendly states is substantial:

Public Policy Protection Texas California New York
Refusing to commit illegal act Yes (Sabine Pilot only) Yes Yes
Reporting illegal activity (general) No state common law protection Yes (broad) Yes (moderate)
Exercising statutory rights Only if specific statute applies Yes (broad) Yes (moderate)
Refusing to violate professional ethics No Yes (for licensed professionals) Sometimes
Internal complaints about violations No Yes (in many cases) Sometimes
Retaliation for safety complaints Only if OSHA or specific statute applies Yes (broad state protections) Yes (moderate)
Implied covenant of good faith No Limited No
Practical result Very few state-law protections; rely on federal law Many avenues for wrongful termination claims More options than TX, fewer than CA

If you moved to Texas from California, your employment rights decreased significantly. Texas courts intentionally keep public policy exceptions narrow to preserve the strong at-will employment doctrine.

Real-World Examples of Public Policy Claims in Texas

These scenarios illustrate when Texas provides protection and when it does not:

Example 1: NO Protection – Reporting Safety Violations

Situation: Carlos worked in manufacturing. He reported unsafe equipment to his supervisor multiple times. His supervisor told him to stop complaining. Carlos filed an internal safety complaint with HR. He was fired two weeks later for “not being a team player.”

Texas Protection: No public policy exception. Carlos was not ordered to commit an illegal act. Sabine Pilot does not apply.

Possible Recourse: Carlos might have OSHA whistleblower protection if he reported to OSHA (not just internally) and files within 30 days. If he only complained internally, he may have no legal recourse.

Example 2: YES Protection – Refusing Illegal Act

Situation: Maria’s supervisor ordered her to alter testing data submitted to the FDA to hide product defects. Maria refused because this was fraud. The supervisor fired her the next week.

Texas Protection: Yes, Sabine Pilot applies. Maria was ordered to commit fraud and fired for refusing.

Possible Recourse: Maria can file a wrongful termination lawsuit in Texas state court within two years.

Example 3: NO Protection – Complaining About Discrimination

Situation: James complained to his manager that he was being treated differently because of his race. The manager disagreed. James was fired one month later. James worked for a company with only 10 employees.

Texas Protection: No public policy exception applies. Complaining about discrimination is not protected under Sabine Pilot.

Possible Recourse: Because the employer has fewer than 15 employees, Title VII does not apply. James likely has no federal or state recourse unless Texas civil rights laws apply (they usually follow federal size thresholds).

Example 4: MAYBE Protection – Reporting Financial Fraud

Situation: Linda discovered her company was submitting false claims to Medicare. She reported this to her supervisor, who told her to stay quiet. Linda reported the fraud to the Department of Health and Human Services. She was fired two weeks later.

Texas Protection: No Sabine Pilot protection (she was not ordered to commit fraud herself, she reported it).

Possible Recourse: Linda may be protected under federal False Claims Act whistleblower provisions. She should consult an attorney immediately to preserve her rights.

Example 5: NO Protection – Refusing Unethical Legal Conduct

Situation: David worked in sales. His manager told him to use high-pressure tactics that David felt were manipulative and predatory toward elderly customers. David refused. He was fired for “not meeting expectations.”

Texas Protection: No. The sales tactics may be unethical but if they do not violate specific consumer protection statutes, Sabine Pilot does not apply.

Possible Recourse: Unless David can prove the tactics violated a specific law (fraud statute, deceptive trade practices), he has no claim.

Example 6: YES Protection (Federal) – Retaliation for Discrimination Complaint

Situation: After filing an EEOC charge alleging sex discrimination, Patricia was fired. Her employer claimed poor performance but Patricia had consistently positive reviews.

Texas Protection: No state public policy exception.

Possible Recourse: Yes, federal law. Title VII prohibits retaliation for filing EEOC charges. Patricia can pursue a retaliation claim separate from her discrimination claim.

Example 7: NO Protection – Internal Ethics Complaint

Situation: Susan, a lawyer working as in-house counsel, complained to the CEO that the company was engaged in behavior that violated her professional ethical obligations (but was not criminal). She was fired for “lack of business judgment.”

Texas Protection: No. Texas does not recognize a public policy exception for professionals refusing to violate ethical standards unless the conduct is illegal.

Possible Recourse: Susan may have no recourse unless she can prove the conduct violated a specific law (triggering Sabine Pilot) or statutory protection applies.

Example 8: MAYBE Protection – Workers’ Comp Retaliation

Situation: After filing a workers’ compensation claim for a back injury, Miguel was fired. His employer said it was due to restructuring, but the timing was suspicious.

Texas Protection: Not under public policy exception, but Texas has a specific statute prohibiting retaliation for filing workers’ comp claims.

Possible Recourse: Miguel should consult an attorney about the Texas Workers’ Compensation Act anti-retaliation provisions. This is statutory protection, not common law public policy.

Example 9: NO Protection – Refusing to Work Off the Clock

Situation: Nicole refused her manager’s instruction to clock out and then continue working. She was fired for “insubordination.”

Texas Protection: Questionable whether this is protected under Sabine Pilot. The conduct may violate wage and hour laws, which could trigger the exception. However, Texas courts have not clearly addressed this.

Possible Recourse: Nicole may have a claim under the Fair Labor Standards Act or Texas Payday Law for unpaid wages and retaliation. See our guide to Texas Wages and Hours.

Example 10: NO Protection – Jury Duty

Situation: Richard was fired for missing work to serve on a jury.

Texas Protection: Not under public policy exception, but Texas has a specific statute prohibiting termination for jury duty.

Possible Recourse: Richard can sue under the Texas jury duty protection statute (not as a common law wrongful termination claim).

What to Do If You Think Your Termination Violated Public Policy

If you believe your Texas employer fired you in violation of public policy, take these steps:

1. Determine whether your situation fits Sabine Pilot. Were you ordered to commit a specific illegal act? Did you refuse? Were you fired because of that refusal? If yes to all three, you may have a state law claim.

2. Research whether a specific statute applies. Many protections come from specific federal or state statutes, not common law public policy. Review:

  • Federal anti-discrimination and anti-retaliation laws
  • OSHA whistleblower provisions
  • Industry-specific whistleblower statutes
  • Texas statutes for jury duty, workers’ comp retaliation, etc.

3. Act fast. Many whistleblower statutes have extremely short deadlines—some as short as 11 days. Do not wait weeks or months to investigate your options.

4. Document everything. Write down what happened, save all communications, and list potential witnesses.

5. Consult an employment attorney. Most offer free initial consultations. An experienced attorney can identify which laws might apply to your situation and explain realistic outcomes.

6. Do not sign severance agreements without legal review. Severance packages typically require you to waive legal claims. Make sure you understand what you are giving up.

7. Set realistic expectations. Most terminations in Texas that feel wrong are legally permissible. If your situation does not fit a specific statutory protection or Sabine Pilot, you likely have no recourse under Texas law.

Learn about filing deadlines in our guide to wrongful termination statute of limitations.

Statute of Limitations for Public Policy Claims

Sabine Pilot claims (common law): Two years from date of termination to file lawsuit in state court.

Federal statutory claims: Vary by statute. Examples:

  • OSHA whistleblower retaliation: 11 to 180 days depending on provision
  • Title VII retaliation: 180-300 days to file EEOC charge
  • Sarbanes-Oxley: 180 days to file with OSHA
  • False Claims Act: Complex timing depending on claim type

State statutory claims: Vary by statute. Examples:

  • Workers’ comp retaliation: Must file within specific timeframe
  • Jury duty retaliation: Check specific statute

Missing these deadlines typically destroys your claim. Do not delay.

Damages for Public Policy Wrongful Termination

If you prove a valid public policy claim, available damages depend on the specific law:

Sabine Pilot claims (state law):

  • Lost wages (back pay)
  • Future lost earnings
  • Emotional distress damages
  • Punitive damages (in egregious cases)
  • Possibly attorney fees

Federal discrimination/retaliation claims:

  • Back pay and front pay
  • Compensatory damages (capped based on employer size: $50K to $300K)
  • Punitive damages (capped)
  • Attorney fees if you prevail

Federal whistleblower claims:

  • Vary by statute; some offer reinstatement, double damages, attorney fees
  • False Claims Act offers percentage of government recovery (potentially substantial)

See our guide to wrongful termination damages for comprehensive information.

Common Questions About Public Policy Exceptions

Does Texas have whistleblower protection?

Very limited. Texas has no general common law whistleblower protection. Federal statutes protect specific types of whistleblowing (OSHA, securities fraud, etc.), and Texas has narrow statutes for public employees and specific industries. Most private sector whistleblowers have no state law protection.

Can I be fired for reporting illegal activity?

Under Texas state law, yes, unless a specific statute protects you. Sabine Pilot does not protect reporting violations—only refusing to commit violations yourself. Check whether federal whistleblower laws apply to your situation.

What if my termination violated company policy?

Company policies generally do not override at-will employment in Texas. Your employer can violate their own policies when firing you (unless you have a contract). Policy violations might be evidence of discrimination if applied inconsistently, but are not independently illegal.

Can I sue for wrongful termination if I was fired for complaining to HR?

It depends what you complained about. If you complained about discrimination based on a protected characteristic (race, sex, disability, etc.) and were fired in retaliation, federal law may protect you. If you complained about non-discriminatory unfair treatment, you likely have no protection.

Does Texas protect employees who refuse to violate professional ethics?

No, unless the conduct your employer demands is illegal (triggering Sabine Pilot). You can be fired for refusing to do things that violate professional ethics but are not criminal or civilly illegal.

What if I am fired for taking FMLA leave?

FMLA retaliation is prohibited under federal law. However, FMLA only applies to employers with 50+ employees and you must meet eligibility requirements. See our guide to Texas Leave Laws.

Can I be fired for discussing wages with coworkers?

Generally no. The National Labor Relations Act protects workers who discuss pay and working conditions. However, enforcement requires filing charges with the National Labor Relations Board. This is federal statutory protection, not a Texas public policy exception.

What is the difference between public policy claims and statutory claims?

Public policy claims are common law wrongful termination claims based on court decisions (like Sabine Pilot). Statutory claims are based on specific laws passed by legislatures (like Title VII). Statutory claims often have administrative requirements (file with EEOC, OSHA, etc.) and specific deadlines. Public policy claims in Texas are extremely limited.

How do I know which law applies to my situation?

This is complex. An experienced employment attorney can review your facts and identify applicable statutes. Do not assume you know which laws apply—many statutes have specific requirements and exceptions.

The Reality of Public Policy Protections in Texas

Texas provides minimal state-law public policy protection for workers. The Sabine Pilot exception is the only recognized common law protection, and it is extremely narrow.

Most wrongful termination protections in Texas come from specific federal statutes, not state law. These statutes have procedural requirements, short deadlines, and apply only in specific circumstances.

If your termination feels unjust but does not fit within Sabine Pilot or a specific statute, Texas law likely provides no recourse. This is the reality of Texas’s employer-friendly at-will employment doctrine.

Before pursuing legal action, get a realistic assessment from an attorney experienced in Texas employment law. Many situations that would support claims in other states provide no remedy in Texas.

References

Disclaimer: The information provided on this page is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Employment laws vary by state and change frequently. For advice specific to your situation, please consult with a licensed employment attorney in your state. Employment Law Aid is not a law firm and does not provide legal representation.